Letting-the-dust-settle--LA-Noire Letting the dust settle: LA Noire

   14/06/2012 at 10:17       Phil May       7 COMMENTS. - Score 5/5
 - LA Noire, Rockstar, Team Bondi, Multiformat, Detective Noir

Smokey Jazz and the seething sinful underbelly of Hollywoodland, two parts to a gin-fizz cocktail that's still as heady as it was over a year ago when LA Noire first sprang out of the loins of Team Bondi / Rockstar Games. It changed the way we look at character animation in games forever. 

Or did it? You see, I stupidly expected that it would lead to some sort of a divine revolution in gaming. One that never arrived, or perhaps one that was destined to be nothing but a pipe dream.

Something recently complelled me to go back to the game, play it through and see if the initial 'wow' factor had subsided at all. With this as my fourth play through I expected LA Noire to be a breeze, expected to remember intimately the conversations, the red herrings and the sleazy shenanigans of the game's bad (and good) guys but it's odd, selective memory and the utterly convincing performances by the game's character actors still catch me out just like they did the first couple of times around. 

So is LA Noire still as stunning and jaw-dropping to look at? Oddly enough it is (even though I seem to notice the glaring jaggies and pixel misfires of this generation's console games more and more), and it shows just how the industry so easily settled back into its stock-in-trade techniques and animation choices that it's still a jarring jolt to see LA Noire's characters properly lip-synching, properly moving with all those delicious little random chaotic facial (and in some cases body language) details that won me over when I first played the game.

Comparing and contrasting with cherry-picked in-game (not cut-scene) footage from this year's E3, it would appear that developers still think full facial animation and mocap are too much like hard work. The new Gears of War prequel still has the square-headed goons muppet-mouthing their way through their tedious dialogue. Square Enix's Tomb Raider reboot still sees Lara failing to range through a fair set of facial expressions despite being pounded, pummelled and kicked to pieces. 

Even David (Quantic Dream) Gage's best attempts to better the 'old fashioned' techniques (his words to describe LA Noire last year, not mine) employed by MotionScan still result in some weird android-like performances, not so much uncanny valley as Valley of the Dolls. 

Sadly it seems that Team Bondi were destined to spontaneously combust once LA Noire was completed, and despite heavy investment in time and money from Rockstar Games, the dazzling tech behind the game's stunning 'acted' performances seems to have been quietly brushed under the carpet, and not adopted elsewhere (certainly from what we've seen of GTA V and definitely nowhere in evidence in Max Payne either, despite the descriptions of how cinematic the game's action scenes are). 

On replaying LA Noire, one thing that screamed out to me more than anything else was how like a classic 90s adventure game it really is once you strip away the by-the-numbers gun fights or the oddly tedious and tricky driving (something I was wholly forgiving of first time around but with a year's worth of gaming between then and now, I really can't get on with the traffic in the game any more!) The interrogation scenes, and the gathering of evidence are still amazingly compelling and it's actually these gameplay mechanics that I'd love to see expanded on if anyone was ever brave enough to tackle a game of this scope again. 

Above all else though, it's the setting that wins it over for me. Shovelling down a gravelly dirty undercurrent of vice and corruption sliding away under a pastel-shaded facade of 1940s Hollywood, it's completely captivating and immersive still. Blink a few times (particularly in black and white mode) and you could be watching a classic film noir like The Maltese Falcon, with the completely unlikeable Phelps taking the place of Bogart. 

The neat segue between each case (with those big bold faux-perspective fonts screaming out the title of each chapter) ramps up the tension as you see a preview of the events leading up to you turning up, partner in tow, to sift through the remains of yet another human drama and even when you're replaying the game it's possible to pick up on things that weren't so obvious first time round, but catch your eye with the benefit of hindsight. 

Now and again the character performances throw you a curveball (particularly when you're interrogating women, in LA Noire they're just so bloody good at lying through their teeth while hiding the fact that they're cold-hearted murderers) but it adds to the experience of picking through the case to gain the highest commendation at the end without dropping horrible clangers along the way (though, as I originally said when I reviewed the game for her, it's actually worth seeing Captain Donnelly losing his rag, such a bloody superb performance from Andrew Connolly).

Just like a year ago, it's eerie picking through the game's IMDB entry and seeing the real faces of the actors involved in LA Noire, and instantly recognising them from the game (and vice versa), in fact I still see fleeting glimpses of them in films, using the same facial expressions (and often the same voices) and knowing exactly who they are. Testament to the fact that MotionScan was a technology that really did provide a solid basis for actors to extend their performances far beyond just lending their voices to characters. Imbuing them with their likeness in every respect must've felt like a breath of fresh air for most character performers working on the game. 

Rockstar is still pretty tight-lipped on the possibility of revisiting LA Noire, though it's not been ruled out. Brendan McNamara is still out there creating games and his next project, "Whore of the Orient" is a good long away away but you can bet as soon as it breaks cover, it's going to have the eyes of the gaming world scrutinising its emergence. 

There's still a ton of potential in games like LA Noire and Hollywood in the 40s and 50s is ripe and fertile soil to reap more stories from so let's hope that the game won't become a shining example of the current generation's technology being pushed to its limits to provide something that still wows to this day. 


User Comments:

You must sign up for an AATG account and login in order to post comments

billdoor - on 14/06/2012 at 11:10 wrote:
still haven't got round to buying this. Can't imagine finding the time to play it though :(

peej - on 14/06/2012 at 11:35 wrote:
It'd be a better investment than pissing away 170 quid on a vita.

It's fairly easy to get through, and because of the way the thing's set out (in chapters) it's quite easy to polish off a case a night. Though of course once you get into it, it's very difficult to stop playing.

billdoor - on 14/06/2012 at 12:02 wrote:
Is it being ported to Vita? :D

evilashchris - on 14/06/2012 at 17:01 wrote:
Playing this through with my wife at the moment, I do the driving and shooting and sharon makes all the conversation choices. It's great fun, and as you say, really to pop in for an episode when you fancy one.

peej - on 14/06/2012 at 17:28 wrote:
I only do any of the driving bits whenever I absolutely have to (like during car chases etc). It's probably a combination of the floaty 30s/40s cars and some serious traffic in LA Noire's city streets that means I am literally crashing into something every 5 ft. Much easier to just let my partner get us to each scene.

The shooting is OK though, pretty much how I'd love GTA V's shooty bits to be.

repairmanjack - on 14/06/2012 at 18:09 wrote:
A great game (and I have three cases left to finish). Not one for the Ritalin crowd, and I suspect that's why it came in for some flak. A couple of flaws, but a fantastic adventure.

(I think of it as the successor to those point and clickers we loved years ago.)

Syrok - on 14/06/2012 at 19:12 wrote:
I actually started playing this for the first time last weekend. Managed to play through the first two desks, I think.
I'm enjoying it quite bit and actually quite like the handling of the cars. The only thing that puts me off a bit is the extreme mood swings of the main character.
And I'm finding it a bit too easy to tell whether suspects are lying or not. Pretty much all of them look up and to the right... And when you are in doubt you can just push doubt which seems to be the right answer in almost all cases. :)

Moving around the head of a dead person is a bit creepy though. Especially when the faces look so good.

Speaking of that, it's a shame that the rest of the animations and details can't keep up with the faces. It makes the faces stick out in weird way.

7 comment(s) in total.
NAIRI: Tower of Shirin Review (0) (09/01)
Point and Squee
Darksiders 3 Review (0) (21/12)
The Filth and the Fury
Call of Cthulhu Review (0) (08/11)
Fishy Goings On
Red Dead Redemption 2 Review (0) (07/11)
Wicky Wicky Wild Wild West
NAIRI: Tower of Shirin Review (0) (09/01)
Point and Squee
Darksiders 3 Review (0) (21/12)
The Filth and the Fury
Call of Cthulhu Review (0) (08/11)
Fishy Goings On
Red Dead Redemption 2 Review (0) (07/11)
Wicky Wicky Wild Wild West
Hearthstone Beta Review - Gather Round (1) (24/02)
Gather Round Blizzard's Latest Cash-Cow
Dream: The Hypersloth Interview - Part 3 (0) (18/11)
Fears before bedtime
Dream: The Hypersloth Interview - Part 2 (2) (17/11)
I can't get no sleep...
Angband Retrospective (4) (25/10)
Learn to fear the letter D.
Why TitanFall is no Call of Duty Killer (5) (18/02)
But it's still bloody marvellous
Gioteck's PS3 Controller Range - Preview (0) (01/08)
Striving for excellence
Havin' a Go: Mass Effect 3 Multiplayer (4) (27/10)
Don't cry wolf just yet...
Shank 2 Set to Kick Your Ass in Early 2012 (0) (26/10)
Not actually a protein. Go on, google it.

Better late than never, eh Ror?
Khanivor - In response to: Battle Chasers: Nightwar Review - 246day(s) ago.
Enjoyed this, cheers!
evilashchris - In response to: Reflecting on the Life of a Tomb Raider - 331day(s) ago.
Looks who's back. Shady's back.
GOD - In response to: Sniper Elite 4 Review - Xbox One - 661day(s) ago.
Micro Machines was my favourite!
ClaytonNotClive - In response to: Mantis Burn Racing Review - 703day(s) ago.
i agree chris, the Aliens table makes the others look bad.. because its so goood!! but they arent that bad.. haha! ...
neosalad - In response to: Aliens Vs. Pinball Review - 964day(s) ago.